Rug Pad Guide: Rug Pad Thickness, Size, Materials (& What to Avoid)

Updated: February, 2021.

Want a comfortable rug pad that doesn’t slip all over the place?

Or maybe you just want something to protect your expensive rug or new floors.

Being around floors for the last 10 years, I’ve seen what types of rug pads damage floors, what features annoy homeowners, and the rug pads people love for years.

Now, the goal of this article is to help you figure out the best rug pad for your home (the exact pad specs you need varies based on a few of your home features… more on that later).

If you want help finding a pre-qualified installer, HomeAdvisor is a company I recommend because they do the homework on the installer for you. Click here to enter your zip code and get connected with 3 installers in your area OR call this number instead: (888) 231-5203. I get a small commission if you use their service, but I believe it’s a great service.

How to choose rug padding

I’ll walk you through buying a rug pad like a good salesman would. But since I don’t work for a rug manufacturer or don’t get paid to push a specific product,  you don’t have to worry about a sales pitch.

Here’s what we’ll cover:

  1. Benefits of rug padding: It’s important to decide what’s important to you because that will lead you to the type of rug pad you need
  2. What size rug pad you need: This will be straightforward based on your rug size.
  3. Best type of rug pad: What material is best for your home, and which materials you should avoid.
  4. Rug-floor compatibility: Some floor materials are notorious for staining or degrading with certain pad materials.
  5. Rug pad thickness: Thickness starts at about 1/16″ and goes up to 8 times thicker. That can have big impact on how it performs, feels, and costs.
  6. My final recommendations: There’s no one rug pad for everybody, but here’s my best shot at the best rug pad for most people.

I’d recommend going through this guide from top to bottom, but you’re welcome to skip to any of the sections listed above by clicking the links.

P.S. This is my most detailed guide on rug padding, but if you just want answers to the best rug pad for hardwood or laminate flooring, you can click that link.

Benefits of rug padding

Rug padding benefits illustration

Rug pads are not just an upsell for the rug sellers. They bring several benefits to both your floor and your area rug.

The most important benefit is that the rug pad will keep your rug from slipping and getting bunched up. Bunched up or sliding rugs are a safety issue and potential tripping hazard for everyone, but especially kids, pets, and people with limited mobility. With the right rug pad, the rug will stay flat even on a smooth surface.

Did I say reducing slipping was the biggest benefit? On second thought, maybe it’s the fact that it protects your floor and rug. This is especially true if you have an expensive rug. The padding will give a cushion, just like carpet pad does to carpet, that keeps the rug from wearing out prematurely. But it also protects the floor. Some rug backings are abrasive to the floor beneath it. A good rug pad should prevent this.

And there’s also the benefit of insulation. This is a smaller benefit since the rug usually isn’t over your whole home, but it provides insulation against cold floors (so your feet stay warm) and sound.

rug pad guide

Captain’s notice! When I link to a rug pad, I may get a small commission from Amazon based on what you buy. This does not affect what you pay or what I recommend. I only link to rug pads I would consider buying if I were in your shoes, and any commission helps pay the bills of the site.

What size rug pad do I need?

Rug pad size illustration

The first question you’ll come across is what size rug pad do you need.

As you can guess, it’s based on the size of your rug. Here are some common rug sizes, and the size of the rug pad you’ll need:

Rug Size Pad Size
9×12 8’10″x11’10”
8×11 7’10″x10’10”
8×10 7’10″x9’10”
5×8 4’10″x7’10”
5×7 4’10″x6’10”

Side note: Amazon can actually be a pretty good resource for area rug padding. In particular, there is a “rug store” on Amazon I like. They let you filter by size, and you can see what other owners think of them, and what rugs they’ve had success with click here to check them out. (note: I receive a small commission if you buy through Amazon, but this doesn’t affect the price you pay).

See the general trend?

The rug pad needed is 2″ shorter in the length and width. This makes a rug pad that is 1″ shorter on all 4 sides. Of course, you can always cut a rug pad that is bigger than your rug, and then trim it down, but definitely don’t go with shorter than the guidelines above!

Materials for rug pads and how they perform

Rug pads materials and how they perform illustration

The material you choose for your rug pad makes a big difference in performance. You’ll

  1. PVC
  2. Felt
  3. Rubber
  4. Felt/Rubber combo
  5. Polyester and/or vinyl

Let’s talk about each briefly, so you can be familiar with their pros and cons:

PVC rug pads are generally less expensive than others, but can cause some problems with the floor. The plastic chemicals do not interact well with vinyl or hardwood floors, causing discoloration or voiding the floor’s warranty. They do make cheap non-slip surfaces. In most cases, I’d avoid PVC pads.

Felt pads are excellent for at extra cushion and support but do not do well at keeping the rug in one place. With larger, heavier rugs this will not be so much of a problem. Their thickness gives some added protection to your floor and more insulation under your feet. Felt pads are considered higher quality since they are great “shock absorbers” to give your rug protection. Here’s a 100% felt pad on Amazon that comes in multiple sizes.

Rubber pads are thin and sticky. They provide a very small amount of cushion and insulation, nothing compared to felt. However, rubber only pads are perfect for smaller rugs where they critical job is keeping it in place. They’re low profile so all you see is the rug; this is especially important for thin and small rugs. Here’s a rubber pad on Amazon in multiple sizes that has good reviews and is fairly inexpensive.

Felt and rubber are the best of both worlds, and my top choice for most homeowners. They give more grip like a rubber pad, but also the comfort and protection of a felt one. Combined pads place felt on the top, to prevent abrasions on the rug’s underside and rubber on the bottom to keep the rug from slipping. For most people with decent quality or better rugs, I think felt and rubber is the way to go. This is my favorite felt and rubber pad on Amazon at a good price. If that pad is too expensive, this is my second favorite felt + rubber pad, cheaper than the previous, but the rubber isn’t quite as high of quality in my opinion.

Polyester and vinyl are usually used for rug to carpet padding. This material does well for preventing the rug from bunching on the carpet but also not damaging the carpet beneath.

rug pad guide

Captain’s warning! If you’re getting a rug for a carpeted floor, it’s important to look for a pad that is specifically a “rug to carpet pad.” Other rug padding designed for hard flooring may not work as well as it should on carpet, but worse, there’s a good chance it will cause your carpet to blossom or fray.

Materials for rug to carpet pads. I’ve received a few questions on specifics of what type of padding is needed for carpet. Usually, the same type of materials are used that are used for hard floors: felt and rubber, but how they are composed can be different. You don’t want the rubber too abrasive on the carpet, and it also helps to have a stiffer felt because the carpet already has some softness and give. Here a carpet to rug pad I recommend.

Still not sure which rug material you want? Your rug size can help you decide…

The last section gave you an overview of each material. And hopefully, it let you narrow down what you want.

There is one more consideration:

The size of your rug can help determine what material you should choose. Different sized rugs have different problems that the rug pad can fix. And depending on the problem to be fixed, different materials will be best:

Small rugs or runners

The smaller the rug, the harder it will be to keep it in one place without some sort of weight or padding. You will also want to keep the pad as thin and lightweight as possible since thicker pads would bring too much bulk underneath a small rug.

For these, a rubber pad is best, but it should allow air to flow freely or it can trap stale odors. The pad should be able to grip both the rug and the floor without sticking to your floor’s finish. That way, the rug will be kept from bunching together or sliding when you walk on it.

Here is my favorite pad to support smaller rugs.

Medium rugs

Medium rugs, loosely defined as those 4-5 feet wide and up to 9 feet long, don’t have quite the “banana peel” effect of smaller rugs where they slide under your feet. However, they still can have problems bunching up.

Unless your rug is under furniture, you’ll want rubber in your pad to grip it. A blended material will do the job best, with the felt side able to grip the rug and the rubber side keeping it together. Usually, a medium rug pad will be between 1/8 and 1/4 of an inch thick.

Here is my favorite pad to support medium rugs (note: this is a fairly thin pad, which I prefer for most medium rugs, but if you want thicker check out my recommendation for large rugs below)

Large rugs

Large area rugs frequently take up most of a room and often have furniture such as couches and chairs placed on top of them. Those will help to hold it in one place, but even then the pads are necessary to keep the rug and the floor in their best condition.

A felt pad is ideal for large rugs that are heavy or bulky enough not to move on their own. They add extra comfort and provide a layer between the floor and the rug so neither of the more valuable items becomes damaged by constantly grating against each other.

If your large rug is in a high traffic area, is thinner, or tends to slide or bunch up to one side, then you would be better off using a combined felt and rubber pad to keep it in one place.

Here is my favorite pad to support large rugs.

Floor compatibility

Floor rug compatibility illustration

We’ve covered materials of rug pads and choosing your rug pad by size, but there is one more thing that may be the most important:

Compatibility with your floor.

One rug pad may work great on carpet, but it might slip on hardwood. Or another rug pad might leave your hardwood looking flawless, but stain luxury vinyl flooring that is under it.

The challenge here is there is no one size fits all answer. However, there are a few things you can consider.

  1. If you’re putting the rug pad on top of vinyl flooring, read the manufacturer’s guide on the vinyl floor. Many prohibit the use of certain pad materials (PVC is a common one)
  2.  If you’re putting the rug pad on carpet, there are carpet specific pads that may be preferred. Rugger based pads could wear on the carpet with time.
  3.  Outside of these two exceptions, most pads are universal with floors like tile and hardwood. However, considering the amount you invested into your floor, I would still read what the manufacturer recommends to be safe.

Rug pad thickness

Rug pad thickness illustration

Another decision you’re going to make is how thick of a rug pad you want.

Some people like to go with the “squish test:” pinch the pad between your fingers and figure out more comfortable.

But there’s more to it than that. The thickness can affect the performance, functionality, and safety.

You’ll find rugs pads anywhere from 1/16″ to ½”. That’s an 8x difference in thickness! Usually, people tend toward thicker pad, but there are times where thick may NOT be better:

  • with a thin or small rug (you don’t want your pad getting more attention than your rug)
  • the rug has to be cleared by a doorway
  • with too thick of a rug (who wants to step over both a thick rug and pad?)

Shameless advertisement that I stand by: Want to shop for rug padding? Click here to check out a rug pad storerug pad guide on Amazon that has great quality and lets you choose by about any size.

Thicker pads are going to cost a little more, and give your rugs more protection. If you have a nice, thick oriental rug, you’ll want to protect it with a thick pad. However, if you have a thinner less expensive rug, you may just want your pad to keep it from slipping. You only need a thin pad to do that.

rug pad guide

Captain’s warning! Don’t forget about your surroundings! While thicker pads are often preferred, be sure that you don’t have a door that opens over the rug, or that the rug is in an area that potentially could be a tripping hazard. These cases a little thinner may be better.

Captain’s parting words!

I hope this helped you pick out the perfect rug pad for you. But if you still want help choosing the best, here are my favorite rug pads for most situations:

  • Most people will want a felt and rubber mix because it gives you all the benefits: cushion, non-slip, insulation, and protection. My favorite felt-rubber pad is this one. These pads can get a little pricey, and if you want more of a budget option, this is second best.
  • If you have a really big rug or a rug that’s under furniture, you may not need the rubber. You can get by with just a felt pad like this one.
  • If you have a small rug, the goal is to keep it from slipping beneath your feet like a banana peel. This rug pad should do the trick.

The rugs I chose above are a fairly standard thickness (in the middle). If you want more cushion, go thicker. If you’re afraid of tripping or it getting in the way, go thinner.

Hope that helps. Let me know if you have any questions in the comments below.

5 9 votes
Article Rating
134 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Shun
1 month ago

Any new recs for rug over carpet. The one you recommended is not available. Thanks!https://www.rugpadusa.com/products/carpet-lock

Peter
4 months ago

Hi,

I have an 6’x9′, 3/8″ thick wool area rug and am looking for a pad. It’ll be on Saltillo tile, so a hard but uneven surface. It’s also have a coffee table on it. It sounds like you generally recommend a 7/16″ felt and rubber pad for large area rugs. What thickness would you recommend?

I’ve never had a rug like this before and am concerned that 13/16″ total thickness might be too thick, but perhaps this thickness would be pretty standard?

Thanks!

Lynn
6 months ago

The carpet to rug pad you recommend is no longer available. Do you have another suggestion? Look for something to accommodate runners on top of my wall-to-wall. Thanks.

Editor
Carpet Captain
5 months ago
Reply to  Lynn

I recommend different products in this article, could you be more specific? Please share the link to the unavailable product.

Sue
6 months ago

Greetings:

My rug is 5’3”x7’10. Is a 5×8 pad close enough? I can take off 2” from short side. But is 5’ to short for a 5’3” rug? It’s an inch shorter than recommended. Thanks.

Editor
Carpet Captain
5 months ago
Reply to  Sue

Hi,

I would say it’s close enough, just trim it down so that the rug pad fits better, as per the guide.

Noreen
7 months ago

What is the best tool to cut the felt/rubber pad combo?

Editor
Carpet Captain
7 months ago
Reply to  Noreen

Hi,

I recommend using a sharp utility knife – change blades as necessary because sharpness is important! Use a long straight edge, such as a 2 x 4, to compress and stabilize the padding by standing on it, so that it’s easier to cut.

Good luck!

134
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x